Skip to navigation Skip to main content
Jenna Collins

Lessons on experimental government

finnish government

Given the current and – following George Osbourne’s budget tomorrow – future financial challenge facing the public sector, Nesta’s seminar on Finland’s basic income experiment was timely. Like most people at the event, I was there to learn more about the conditions necessary to design, test and scale a new – and somewhat radical – policy idea.

Roope Mokka from Demos Helsinki spoke enthusiastically about the journey of the Basic Income experiment so far, and what was to come. He also outlined some of the key conditions/principles that had guided the experiment to date:

Agency from the top down: Basic Income sits within a wider Finnish government programme to rethink public services

Policy through experiments: The Government and its civil servants want to change the way they do policy, recognising that the current way is not delivering the desired outcomes

Not thinking within an existing system: Truly building a new system from the bottom-up, rather than making tweaks.

Although they have some way to go to making Basic Income a reality, the right components are in place for policy makers and partners to create a new, needs-driven system.

The lessons I took from the event:

Freedom (permission?) to innovate and change is important. To what extent do UK public services have that genuine freedom? (Devolution has a role to play here)

Experimentation is clearly a good thing. It’s a pillar of IMPOWER’s approach to co-design. We have run numerous trials to test whether what we have co-designed with the client actually works

Using a networked approach. The Finnish Government in this instance are acting as a coordinator; managing a network of partners and collaborators who are pitching and testing ideas. This is the future of policy design (and public sector leadership – see Martin Cresswell’s blog on this)

The scale and ambition of the Basic Income experiment is impressive. It’s hard to imagine Whitehall adopting a similar approach to design and scale new policy ideas. But for CCGs and local government? Looking at the projects organisations like IMPOWER are working on using similar methodologies, it actually feels eminently possible.

Photo credit: Eduskuntatalo via photopin (license)

Other relevant insight

It’s Time to Care!

The NHS Time for Care scheme will be fully rolled out over the next three years following a successful pilot, but what is the extent of avoidable demand? I share my views on this much needed scheme.

April 17, 2019

Ealing’s ASC placement spend down 5% – how did they do it?

The second instalment of our EDGEWORK Series – launched today – is a guide to Primed Performance Management (PPM), and includes a case study detailing how the use of PPM in our work with Ealing Council helped them to reduce costs and improve outcomes.

April 11, 2019

New Children’s Commissioner report highlights a national scandal

'Early access to mental health support' report shows that there is insufficient lower level preventative support available

April 10, 2019


Sign up for the latest thinking on delivering sustainable change and better public services

No spam; unsubscribe easily at any time. Learn more in our Privacy Policy.