Skip to navigation Skip to main content
IMPOWER

The lesson from the Birmingham judgement – do the same as Birmingham Council, not the opposite!

I have discussed the Birmingham judgement (on 20th May, overturning Birmingham’s decision to move to supporting critical needs only) with a number of directors of adult social care and other key players, and very different views are emerging about what it means.

I want to make my view clear. The judgement:

  • does not undermine overall Council savings targets and means local government will get more money
  • does not mean adult social care will get away with lower cuts, it is not a victory
  • does mean that there is considerable anxiety and nervousness about how adult social care cuts are planned and delivered.

There is a negative and a positive response to this.

Negative – box ticking consultation and impact assessment, avoiding really listening, focusing cuts on those who are least able to stand up for themselves and complain

Positive – genuinely engage and listen and “co-produce” a new social care offer through this unprecedented challenge

Ironically, Birmingham’s open, listening, extensive consultation meant they were at the forefront of taking a risk on this positive route, and it was largely this that led them into this trouble. It would be understandable for Strategic Director Peter Hay, to now take the negative cautious line. However, Peter gets full marks for committing to continue with the positive route.

Jeremy Cooper, director, IMPOWER Consulting

Other relevant insight

Public services thought leader, innovator or change enthusiast? Join us at an IMPOWER learning event

At IMPOWER we are committed to helping local authorities deliver better public services. Our learning events convene thought leaders, innovators and enthusiasts from across the sector.

July 16, 2019

Reflections from ADCS 19

I share my reflections on the recent Association of Directors of Children’s Services (ADCS) Annual Conference.

July 15, 2019

Which councils are best at supporting children with high needs?

Our Top 10 ranking of councils in relation to high needs has today been published by The MJ.

July 4, 2019

IMPOWER INSIGHT newsletter

Sign up for the latest thinking on delivering sustainable change and better public services

No spam; unsubscribe easily at any time. Learn more in our Privacy Policy.

Close
Close